How we rate
Every product on this site is described from two kinds of information, and we label which is which.
What we use today
- Makers' figures: capacity, dimensions, shelf life and storage claims, as the maker publishes them.
- Prices seen: the price on a named retailer's page on the date at the top of the guide.
- Arithmetic: price per gallon and filled weight at 8.34 pounds a gallon.
What we have not done yet
We have not tested any product hands-on. No rating on this site is based on our own use. When we start testing, each result will be marked as tested, with the date and the method.
The tests we plan
- Fill: time to fill, and whether it needs a funnel or hose.
- Carry: one adult, a flight of stairs, full.
- Stack: full, for thirty days.
- Drop: full, from waist height.
- Pour: whether you can fill a glass without spilling.